NoSlaves.com

Cyberactivism on Trade, Economics and Labor Arbitrage

NoSlaves.com header image 2

John Edwards is a Hypocrite

September 4th, 2007 · 11 Comments

John Edwards Makes Me Mad.  I’m sorry, I’m a Democrat but I have to say that.  The reason I say that is he claims to be for working America yet clearly is out to labor arbitrage American Professional workers through the expansion of the H-1b Visa program.
teacher pointer

From September 03, 2007 San Jose Mercury News:

EDWARDS: Regarding the H-1B visa question: I think it is important for us to have available, for the work that’s being done here in this valley, plus all over the country, the talent and the mental capacity we need.

So the H-1B visa program is important; it should be expanded, based on the needs that exist.

Also important is that America needs to be doing a much better, more-effective job in producing, from our own young people, the talent pool that can perform these jobs, and my view is that we are not concentrating on science and math the way that we need to. We’re not concentrating on graduate education in those areas the way we need to.

But immigration is a very hot topic out there in America, and a very divisive topic. You can be in front of a group of progressive Democrats, and there will be a lot of people in the room who want to know what you’re going to do about the illegal immigrants, and they’re not thinking about a path to citizenship. Secondly, I do think we should be tougher on employers who are knowingly violating the law, and in many cases, abusing workers. But the third piece, and this is the more controversial one, I do think that there should be a path to citizenship, and it needs to be a meaningful path to citizenship.

I think the path that was in the bill that was last considered by the Senate was completely unrealistic. I mean most undocumented workers in America would never meet that standard, which means they would never become American citizens. And I don’t want to live in a country that’s made up of first-class citizens and second-class laborers. That’s not America

delete consultant

Oh really John? What is YOUR America? One where the best jobs in the country are labor arbitraged through massive increases in guest worker Programs? Look at the hypocrisy of this paragraph! He claims that he doesn’t want a two tier society but the first thing he wants is to expand a program to send highly skilled and educated American professionals to the poor house!

It’s well known there is NO WORKER SHORTAGE and it is also well known that the H-1B Visa program is being used to labor arbitrage American workers.

Yet there he is promising to throw more U.S. citizens under a bus, completely ignoring the overwhelming evidence that the H-1B guest worker Visa is harming American professional workers.

And his great help to protect United States Professional workers in the Senate? Well, to cosponsor one of the largest H-1B guest worker Visas in history.

Is that why you promised Silicon valley executives more labor arbitraging guest worker Visas?

Look, here he is at a India PAC organization. I just wrote a story on how this organization is representing India’s, not America’s interests.

Here’s the ILW pointing this out.

So, as Silicon valley demands Democrats throw U.S. workers to the dogs, what kind of financial haul did Edwards get?
at least $3.1 million.

ATM machine

And one must ask themselves if Google, Microsoft and Oracle actually paid US workers that money instead of trying to buy off Presidential Candidates and congress representatives would there be an overall financial savings? That’s a lot of dough being spread in the great desire to screw over U.S. workers.

Or is it that the AILA is busy making individual campaign contributions so you really want to make sure you butter their bread through enabling their industry of processing guest worker Visas?

Now if ya all think I’m being harsh on Edwards, well, the reality is many activists have tried to not only point out this horrific position to the campaign, they have also presented Edwards with study after study on how there is no worker shortage and how this program is a glorified offshore outsourcing and labor arbitrage system. Does he care? Obviously NOT!

Here is his voting record on guest worker Visas:

Cosponsored legislation to import more low-skill foreign workers in 2004
Sen. Edwards cosponsored S. 2252, the Save Summer Act of 2004. Introduced by Senator Edward Kennedy (D-MA), S. 2252 would have raised the annual cap on H-2B visas for 2004 by 40,000, for a total of 106,000 H-2B visas. This would have allowed thousands of low skill foreign workers to enter the U.S. and compete with American workers.

Voted for a foreign worker bill with no anti-fraud measures in 2000.
Sen.Edwards voted for S.2045, the Abraham foreign worker bill to nearly triple the number of foreign high-tech workers. On the heels of the release of a GAO report finding no proof of a high-tech worker shortage and evidence of abuse in the H-1B program, Sen. Edwards voted for this foreign worker bill that contained no worker protections or anti-fraud measures. The bill passed the Senate 96-1

I’m sorry but to claim to be for working America is despicable, it’s disgusting!  At least Hillary makes no bones about the fact she’s in the pocket of NASSCOM!

This pretense of a populist position is an old wolves in sheep’s clothing tale.  I find it much worse for one pretends to be in favor of working America…like the fox who proclaims to be a chicken simply to gain access to the hen house!

Fox in the Hen House

For anyone reading this, there is one Democrat standing tall for Professional workers and that is Dennis Kucinich.

We’re not alone in this outrage. Here’s another blogger calling Edwards Marie Antoinette.

One of the best quotes I’ve seen on the blogs is:

John Edwards knows a lot about poverty, after all, he’s helped throw a lot of people into it

UPDATE: Edwards has recent statements which show he may be actually listening to professional workers on guest worker Visas, click here to read about it.  Also, if you are looking for Obama to not sell out US workers, think again, he has promised corporate lobbyists whatever they want to labor arbitrage Americans as bad as Hillary has.

Share and Recommend: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Fark
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Technorati
  • Smarking
  • SphereIt
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Webride
  • Netscape
  • TailRank
  • Shadows
  • Blue Dot
  • StumbleUpon
  • NewsVine
Email This Post To A Friend Email This Post To A Friend

Tags: Election '08 · Labor · H-1B

 

 

RSS Comments Feed

spacer Comment by Info_Tech_Guy
+2 votes
  + -
2007-09-04 15:02:16

Having voted for Edwards in ‘04, I must say that I’m terribly disappointed in him in ‘07.

Edwards comes across as if he does not give a damn about American white collar workers – as if Edwards is willing to throw American workers under the bus if it means getting lots of tech industry/business lobbyist money.

Edwards looks pretty and he speaks well. He talks like a populist in front of factory workers but he rakes in the dough like the insider corporate lobbyists he allegedly despises when he’s talking to business groups.

Does anyone know who the real John Edwards is? (Does John Edwards even know???) Edwards talks about the “rich and poor” but ignores the fact that the middle class is being destroyed.

Was Edwards lesson from the ’04 election that opposition to offshore outsourcing American middle class jobs was not “effective” in an election?

I’ve really had enough of cynical politicians and the way that they and their supporters try to convince people disgusted with the destruction of middle class life that they deserve support because they are essentially, the lesser evil.

Sorry, Hillary Clinton and John Edwards are both headed in the same direction as “W” on economic policy — more “free trade” and more offshore outsourcing of middle class jobs…

 
spacer Comment by Charles
+1 votes
  + -
2007-09-04 15:03:53

Good blogging. Nice site, too.

 
spacer Comment by Mike
+1 votes
  + -
2007-09-05 11:43:40

John Edwards, my first choice for stopping Hillary Clinton (Democratic chair of the Senate India caucus and friend to Tata), disappointed me when he took the Silicon Valley bribe and spoke out in support of H-1B. I have since switched to Kucinich.

I think all the other Democrats (except possibly Dodd and Gravel) have some cheap labor slop in their bellies.

Very disappointing.

What makes me really angry however, is the tactic many of them use of opposing outsourcing to gain grass roots support then turning around and supporting these damned guest (indentured) worker visas. The only difference between an American job lost to a foreign worker working in Mountain View and an American job lost to a foreign worker working in Hyberabad is that someone can claim the job is “being kept in America”.

Lying scum.

 
spacer Comment by Anonymous
+1 votes
  + -
2007-09-05 14:24:04

There is no hope on democratic side for honest support of protecting the jobs - Clintons are fully beholden to H1b lobby and Bill was the one who increased them to 195,000 per year and opened the floodgates in the 90s.
Your only chance is with republican tancredo and while he is not president material he is VERY honest in his views on immigration including H1b and can create enough noise in the campaign to influence the voters and other candidates.

spacer Comment by Bob Oak
not yet rated
  + -
2007-09-05 14:33:34

There is no way we or most Progressives would support Tancredo due to his anti-choice, anti-science positions, anti-labor, trade, social safety nets, pro Iraq war. I think Dennis Kucinich is our only choice here. I know Tancredo has a good position on H-1B but the rest of his agenda is so odious to Progressives and economist populists there is no way we can support him. I also note that while Republicans had control of both houses they did not pass one, not one H-1B Visa reform bill. They didn’t even vote one out of House Judiciary committee. They did hold some very good hearings.

 
 
spacer Comment by Rodger
+1 votes
  + -
2007-09-09 11:57:17

This is depressing. I really thought that Edwards was for the average guy and now to find that he’s basically another smooth talking pretend populist… Bernie Sanders he’s not.

Though the more I think of it, its worse than depressing, its scary. All I see is a continuation of Bush economic policy with the election of any of the top 3 Democrats.

What gets me though is why is the liberal blogosphere so silent not only Hillary’s and Obama corporate connection but Edwards as well, shouldn’t they be warning people about wolfs in sheep clothing rather than being cheerleaders for them? I don’t get it.

 
spacer Comment by 2Truthy
+1 votes
  + -
2007-09-09 15:21:04

This is an excellent article about John Edwards crossing over to the Dark Side (Tech Lobby)and unless he changes his position on this toute suite, he can kiss his chances for the presidency goodbye. Looks like Kucinich is the only guy out there who is standing up for the professional middle class.

(I am the blogger referenced in this post asking the question “Is John Edwards the New Marie Antoinette?”)

How does the Edwards camp think they are going to beat Hillary now by echoing her position on selling out our white collar jobs by “expanding” the H-1b visa cap?

If anything was (note past tense)going to put Edwards in the WH, it would have been the overwhelming economic populist vote that Hillary doesn’t think she needs. I do not get this… Unless, of course, Gore is trotted out as the October surprise Dem candidate and makes Edwards his veep…Remember, Gore, the Energy businessman with ties to Silicon Valley — is on the advisory board at Google, hangs out with Senator Boxer (pro-H-1b) and the Tech Lobby VC frat boys. Or, another scenario is that Hillary will pick Edwards for veep but I still don’t get why Edwards, who has more money than he could ever spend, would want to give the professional middle class the finger and also settle for losing.

spacer Comment by Bob Oak
not yet rated
  + -
2007-09-09 15:37:43

Thx 2Truthy for your article. I hestitate in posting anything critical of a Democrat who has some progressive positions, because we are so needing to move in this overall direction, but on this one, since it’s such a critical issue to American jobs, I just blew a rod frankly. It’s so disappointing when the answers are obvious and promoted by so many progressives, to not see real policy for the nation interest in the Presidential campaigns.

The next blog article has more information and I’m suggesting we ask all of the candidates to sign onto 3 bills already introduced into congress plus promise not to raise the cap until these reforms are implemented.

Thanks for your courage and writing.

 
 
spacer Comment by D Bandy
not yet rated
  + -
2007-09-23 04:36:21

“The next blog article has more information and I’m suggesting we ask all of the candidates to sign onto 3 bills already introduced into congress plus promise not to raise the cap until these reforms are implemented.”

Sorry, I believe we should be working to end H1/L1 visa’s.

 
 
spacer Pingback by NoSlaves.com
not yet rated
  + -
2007-12-06 23:00:00

[…] I wrote a piece exposing Edwards history for promoting more labor arbitraging guest worker Visas, yet in a recent […]

 

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.